Lite Remote EJB Communication

Since Payara Server 5.191

Payara Server has support for classic remote EJB since its inception. Classic remote EJB uses the IIOP-RMI (Internet Inter-ORB Protocol Remote Method Invocation) protocol for transport communication and the CSIv2 (Common Secure Interoperability Protocol Version 2) protocol for security.

While feature rich, these protocols were not designed with firewalls, NAT, (private) clouds, Docker and generally the Internet in mind. For these environments the requirements of the protocol, such as establishing independent connections back from the server to the client, are too troublesome.

The IIOP-RMI/CSIv2 also requires the use of multiple heavyweight client libraries. In the case of Payara Server the client library (either referenced by the gf-client.jar library or the payara-embedded-all dependency) is almost as big as the entire server as it’s essentially a special form of the ACC (Application Client Container). For this reason a much needed modernization of the transport and security protocols was needed, and for the environments described only one protocol really works, and that is the HTTP(S) protocol.

Payara Server Enterprise features an additional complimentary EJB remoting technology based on the HTTP(S) protocol while favoring the use of a thin client library that make remote applications much lighter while circumventing known challenges for the Internet and other scenarios.

HTTP(S) for EJB Remoting in Payara Server is a completely different feature from the classic IIOP-RMI/CSIv2-based feature, and does not intend to replace the transport layer protocol used on it, rather it is implemented as an additional independent feature.

TX Propagation and Security Propagation is not supported by EJB Remoting in Payara Server.

In the current version of this feature, not all remote EJB features are implemented yet.

Configuring HTTP(S) for Remote EJBs

HTTP(S) for EJB remoting in Payara Server makes use of a special web endpoint on which is located by default on the path /ejb-invoker. This endpoint is disabled out of the box and it can be enabled using the set-ejb-invoker-configuration asadmin command.

`set-ejb-invoker-configuration`

Since Payara Server 5.194

Usage

asadmin set-ejb-invoker-configuration
        [--enabled=true|false]
        [--securityenabled=true|false]
        [--roles=<role-list>]
        [--authmoduleclass=<SAM-class>]
        [--authmodule=<security-provider-id>]
        [--realmname=<realm-name>]
        [--authtype=<auth-type>]
        [--endpoint=<context-root[default:ejb-invoker]>]
        [--virtualservers=<virtualserver-list>]
        [--target=<target[default:server]>]

Aim: Enables or disables the endpoint that allows HTTP(S) transport based communication for remote EJBs.

Command Options

Option Type Description Default Mandatory

Option	Type	Description	Default	Mandatory
`enabled`	Boolean	Enables or disables the ejb-invoker application.	true	No
`securityenabled`	Boolean	Whether or not secure access to the ejb-invoker endpoint is enabled.	false	No
`roles`	String	If defined, the endpoint will be assigned to a list of the role specified as a comma-separated..	invoker	No
`endpoint`	String	The context root used to expose the ejb-invoker application endpoint.	ejb-invoker	No
`authmoduleclass`	String	Defines the full qualified class name implementing `javax.security.auth.message.module.ServerAuthModule`. If defined and securityenabled set to true, HttpServlet Message security provider is created and ejb-invoker application secured with configured SAM.		No
`authmodule`	String	Defines the existing message security provider id. If defined and securityenabled set to true, ejb-invoker application secured by security provider.		No
`realmname`	String	Defines the registered realm name. If defined and securityenabled set to true, ejb-invoker application secured and realm used for the authentication.		No
`authtype`	String	The instance or cluster to enable the endpoint.		No
`virtualservers`	String	If defined, the endpoint will be assigned to a list of virtual servers specified as a comma-separated list of names. Otherwise, the endpoint will be assigned to all virtual servers available.		No
`target`	String	The target configuration where the command should be run.	server	No

enabled

Boolean

Enables or disables the ejb-invoker application.

true

securityenabled

Boolean

Whether or not secure access to the ejb-invoker endpoint is enabled.

false

roles

String

If defined, the endpoint will be assigned to a list of the role specified as a comma-separated..

invoker

endpoint

String

The context root used to expose the ejb-invoker application endpoint.

ejb-invoker

authmoduleclass

String

Defines the full qualified class name implementing javax.security.auth.message.module.ServerAuthModule. If defined and securityenabled set to true, HttpServlet Message security provider is created and ejb-invoker application secured with configured SAM.

authmodule

String

Defines the existing message security provider id. If defined and securityenabled set to true, ejb-invoker application secured by security provider.

realmname

String

Defines the registered realm name. If defined and securityenabled set to true, ejb-invoker application secured and realm used for the authentication.

authtype

String

The instance or cluster to enable the endpoint.

virtualservers

String

If defined, the endpoint will be assigned to a list of virtual servers specified as a comma-separated list of names. Otherwise, the endpoint will be assigned to all virtual servers available.

target

String

The target configuration where the command should be run.

server

Example

The following command will enable the endpoint on the DAS:

asadmin > set-ejb-invoker-configuration --enabled=true

The set-ejb-invoker-configuration --enabled=true/false commands actually deploy/undeploy an internal small WAR application that exposes the endpoint. In this version this application is shown in all overviews that show deployed applications once enabled.

`get-ejb-invoker-configuration`

Since Payara Server 5.194

Usage

asadmin get-ejb-invoker-configuration
        [--target=<target[default:server]>]

Aim: Returns the current configuration options for the ejb-invoker application on the targeted configuration.

Command Options

Option Type Description Default Mandatory

Option	Type	Description	Default	Mandatory
`target`	String	The target configuration where the command should be run.	server	No

target

String

The target configuration where the command should be run.

server

Example

The following command returns the current configuration options from the DAS:

asadmin > get-ejb-invoker-configuration --target cluster1

Configuring the Thin Client Dependency

Client applications that wish to use HTTP(S) as the transport protocol when calling remote EJBs will have to use a special thin-client dependency. In order to do this, you can add the following Maven dependency to your client project:

<dependency>
    <groupId>fish.payara.extras</groupId>
    <artifactId>ejb-http-client</artifactId>
    <version>5.28.1</version>
</dependency>

This artifact requires a patched version of the Jersey client which is pulled intransitive. This patched version is available within our [Payara Patched Project repository](https://github.com/payara/Payara_PatchedProjects). The Maven repository definition is present in the pom.xml file of the ejb-http-client artifact. However, when your dependencies are managed by a Company Nexus, for example, you might need to update it to refer to the Payara Patched Project repository.

Also, we recommend having a look at the BOM feature so that versions can be defined more consistently.

Finally, the code that executes the call to the remote EJB must be modified in some manner. To obtain a type-safe proxy for any remote EJB bean, the traditional approach via JDNI is still used. An example is given below:

First, consider the following remote EJB interface:

@Remote
public interface BeanRemote {
    String method();
}

Second, consider a (secured) EJB that implements that interface and resides in a EJB application called "test" deployed on a Payara server instance that is listening in http://localhost:8080:

@Stateless
public class Bean implements BeanRemote, Serializable {

    private static final long serialVersionUID = 1L;

    @Override
    @RolesAllowed("g1")
    public String method() {
        return "method";
    }

}

Given the above, the following client code can be used to obtain a proxy to the BeanRemote bean and invoke a remote method defined on it:

import static javax.naming.Context.INITIAL_CONTEXT_FACTORY;
import static javax.naming.Context.PROVIDER_URL;

import java.util.Properties;
import javax.naming.Context;
import javax.naming.InitialContext;

public class RemoteEJBLiteClient{

    public static void main(String... args) throws NamingException{

        Properties environment = new Properties();
        environment.put(INITIAL_CONTEXT_FACTORY, "fish.payara.ejb.rest.client.RemoteEJBContextFactory");
        environment.put(PROVIDER_URL, "http://localhost:8080/ejb-invoker");

        InitialContext ejbRemoteContext = new InitialContext(environment);

        BeanRemote beanRemote = (BeanRemote) ejbRemoteContext.lookup("java:global/test/Bean");
        beanRemote.method() // returns "method"
    }
}

Calling a Secured Remote EJB

When calling a secured EJB using the ejb-invoker endpoint, there are some considerations in place for the client code:

If the remote EJB is secured with transport confidentiality (and integrity) enabled like this:

<ejb>
    <ejb-name>Bean</ejb-name>
    <ior-security-config>
        <transport-config>
            <integrity>REQUIRED</integrity>
            <confidentiality>REQUIRED</confidentiality>
            <establish-trust-in-target>SUPPORTED</establish-trust-in-target>
            <establish-trust-in-client>SUPPORTED</establish-trust-in-client>
        </transport-config>
    </ior-security-config>
</ejb>

Then, the corresponding HTTP endpoint to use would be https://localhost:8181/ejb-invoker instead.

If the remote EJB also has authentication enabled (via username and password credentials) like this:
```
<ejb>
    <ejb-name>Bean</ejb-name>
    <as-context>
        <auth-method>USERNAME_PASSWORD</auth-method>
        <realm>default</realm>
        <required>true</required>
    </as-context>
</ejb>
```
Then the credentials required to correctly authenticate the user for the call have to be specified in the JNDI context with the following properties:
- javax.naming.Context.SECURITY_PRINCIPAL for the username
- javax.naming.Context.SECURITY_CREDENTIALS for the password

Here’s an example of the complete client code used to call a secured remote EJB:

import static javax.naming.Context.INITIAL_CONTEXT_FACTORY;
import static javax.naming.Context.PROVIDER_URL;
import static javax.naming.Context.SECURITY_CREDENTIALS;
import static javax.naming.Context.SECURITY_PRINCIPAL;

import java.util.Properties;
import javax.naming.Context;
import javax.naming.InitialContext;

public class RemoteEJBLiteClient{

    public static void main(String... args) throws NamingException{

        Properties environment = new Properties();
        environment.put(INITIAL_CONTEXT_FACTORY,"fish.payara.ejb.rest.client.RemoteEJBContextFactory");
        environment.put(PROVIDER_URL, "https://localhost:8181/ejb-invoker");
        environment.put(SECURITY_PRINCIPAL, "u1");
        environment.put(SECURITY_CREDENTIALS, "p1");

        InitialContext ejbRemoteContext = new InitialContext(environment);

        BeanRemote beanRemote = (BeanRemote) ejbRemoteContext.lookup("java:global/test/Bean");
        beanRemote.method() // returns "method"
    }
}

When accessing secured EJBs you should use only HTTPS (that means, enabling confidential transport requirements to the remote EJB), as the submitted credentials will be transferred in clear text (not encrypted, only base64 encoded), which is a security risk you should avoid in any production environment.

JNDI Customization Options

Under the covers the remote EJB proxy uses a JAX-RS (Jersey) REST client builder in order to establish communication with the remote server. If you want to customize and modify the parameters for this communication (timeouts, keystores, etc.) the following JNDI context properties can be used to this end:

Table 1. `JNDI Options for Custom HTTP(S) Communication`
Property	Behaviour	Type
`fish.payara.connectTimeout`	The connection timeout. A value of 0 represents that the wait is indefinite. Negative values are not allowed. Unit is microseconds.	`Number` (from which it’s `Long` value is taken) or a `String` that can be converted to a `Long` value.
`fish.payara.readTimeout`	The timeout to read a response. If the remote Payara doesn’t respond within the defined time a ProcessingException is thrown with a `TimeoutException` as its cause. A value of 0 represents that the wait is indefinite. Negative values are not allowed. Unit is microseconds.	`Number` (from which it’s `Long` value is taken) or a `String` that can be converted to a `Long` value.
`fish.payara.keyStore`	The key store to be used by the proxy. The key store contains the private key as well as certificates with its associated public keys.	Instance of `java.security.KeyStore` or a `String` representing its fully qualified classname.
`fish.payara.trustStore`	The trust store to be used by the proxy. The trust store must contain the certificates that are needed to communicate with the remote Payara Server.	Instance of `java.security.KeyStore` or a `String` representing its fully qualified classname.
`fish.payara.sslContext`	The SSL context that will be used by the proxy for creating secured connections to the Payara remote server. This context must be fully initialized, including the trust and key managers. Should not be used in conjunction with the `fish.payara.keyStore` and/or `fish.payara.trustStore` properties.	Instance of `javax.net.ssl.SSLContext` or a `String` representing its fully qualified classname.
`fish.payara.hostnameVerifier`	The hostname verifier to be used by the proxy to verify the endpoint’s hostname against the identification information of it.	Instance of a `javax.net.ssl.HostnameVerifier` or a `String` representing its fully qualified classname.
`fish.payara.provider.principal`	The principal to be used by the proxy to access the secured endpoint.	Instance of a `String`.
`fish.payara.provider.credentials`	The credentials to be used by the proxy to access the secured endpoint.	Instance of a `String`.
`fish.payara.provider.authType`	To specify the authentication type of the secured endpoint. By default `BASIC` is defined.	Instance of a `String`.
`fish.payara.requestFilter`	To register the custom filter for the client request invoked by proxy.	Instance of a `javax.ws.rs.client.ClientRequestFilter` or a `Class` implementing `javax.ws.rs.client.ClientRequestFilter`.
`fish.payara.responseFilter`	To register the custom filter for the client response received by proxy.	Instance of a javax.ws.rs.client.ClientResponseFilter ` or a `Class implementing `javax.ws.rs.client.ClientResponseFilter`.
`fish.payara.executorService`	The executor service that will be used for executing asynchronous tasks. (for future use)	Instance of `java.util.concurrent.ExecutorService` or a `String` representing its fully qualified classname.
`fish.payara.scheduledExecutorService`	The executor service that will be used for executing scheduled asynchronous tasks. (For future use)	Instance of `java.util.concurrent.ScheduledExecutorService` or string representing fully qualified classname.
`fish.payara.withConfig`	The configuration for the internal JAX-RS/Jersey REST client.	Instance of `javax.ws.rs.core.Configuration` or a `String` representing its fully qualified classname.
`fish.payara.clientAdapter`	Implementation of client side adapter to use for intercepting JNDI lookups (see below)	Instance of `fish.payara.ejb.http.client.adapter.ClientAdapter`

The constants are also exposed as static fields of fish.payara.ejb.rest.client.RemoteEJBContextFactory.

System Properties Fallbacks

The JNDI customization options listed above as well the environment variables defined in javax.naming.Context (except APPLET) can be set by setting a system property of the same name that will act as a fallback. That means it will not override an environment variable that is already present but would be used in the case that it is not defined when InitialContextFactory.getInitialContext is invoked.

Client side adapter

EJB Lite connector is, in its current form, suited for invoking stateless remote EJBs. However, if you’re using the connector with existing clients, those may depend on stateful interactions, like invoking stateful EJBs or accessing application server data sources and connection factories. Client side adapters serve the purpose of emulating stateful behavior at the client and delegate the requests to stateful backend, when all information from the client is collected.

The API of client side adapters is prescribed by interface fish.payara.ejb.http.client.adapter.ClientAdapter:

public interface ClientAdapter {
    /*
     * @param jndiName jndi name requested for lookup
     * @param remoteContext naming context for remote EJB invocation
     * @return Optional.of(proxy) if adapter provides a proxy for given name, Optional.empty() otherwise
     * @throws NamingException if downstream lookup fails, or other validation doesn't pass
     */
    Optional<Object> makeLocalProxy(String jndiName, Context remoteContext)
        throws NamingException;

}

To make use of the adapter, put an instance of ClientAdapter into JNDI context property fish.payara.clientAdapter. Every JNDI lookup will be first passed to the adapter instance in such case. If adapter returns non-empty Optional, that return value is passed back to the client.

Composing multiple adapters

Client side emulation might require stubbing diverse JNDI names and return types, and handling all of that in a single ClientAdapter implementation would result in not very maintenable code. Therefore the client library offers two classes that help with composition of multiple Client adapters into the parent instance to be passed to RemoteEJBContextFactory:

CompositeClientAdapter concatenates multiple client adapter instances, calling adapters in a defined order and returning first non-empty proxy provided by the adapters.
ClientAdapterCustomizer is a decorator, that helps separate JNDI name matching from instantiation of client adapter. Most used method of customizer is matchPrefix, which will only call downstream adapter when requested JNDI name matches prefix. This prefix is stripped before invoking the downstream adapter.

Composite Client Adapter example

Properties props = new Properties();
props.put(Context.INITIAL_CONTEXT_FACTORY, RemoteEJBContextFactory.FACTORY_CLASS);
props.put(Context.PROVIDER_URL, "http://not.relevant/");
props.put(RemoteEJBContextFactory.CLIENT_ADAPTER,
        CompositeClientAdapter.newBuilder()
            .register(customize(new ConnectionFactoryAdapter()).matchPrefix("jms/")
                    customize(QueueAdapter.class).matchPrefix("queue/"))
            .build()
        );
Context context = new InitialContext(props);

See API documentation of the client library for detailed description of ClientAdapterCustomizer methods and contracts of CompositeClientAdapter.

Known Limitations

Serialization Limitations

HTTP adapter utilizes JSON-B for serialization. This places limits on types of objects that can be transmitted as method arguments or return types. The serialization can be customized by means of JSON-B annotations.

By default, only public properties and fields are transferred
Complex object graphs should form a tree and not contain cyclic references
Polymorphism is not supported by default

Programming Model Limitations

HTTP adapter uses staless HTTP requests. In current form, it is therefore unfit for invoking stateful objects like @Stateful Enterprise Java Beans, or using server resources like DataSource or ConnectionFactory.